Rethinking Development Finance: A New Approach to MSME Lending

Picture1

One of the most cited figures in development economics is the large financing gap in for Micro, Small and Medium-sized firms in sub-Saharan Africa, estimated at $331 billion and for good reason. It represents not just an abstract shortfall in capital flows but a concrete ceiling on the productive capacity of the businesses that employ the majority of Africa’s working-age population. At both regional and national levels, Development finance institutions have acknowledged this gap, committed to addressing it, and, in many cases, significantly scaled up their lending facilities for MSMEs over the past decade. And yet the gap persists. In fact, the latest estimates show the gap is growing.

This is primarily not a function of insufficient capital. The aggregate capitalization of Development Finance Institutions (DFIs) operating in Africa has grown substantially over the same period. It reflects a fundamental mismatch between how DFI lending products are designed and the operating realities, risk profiles, and documentation capacities of the MSMEs they are nominally meant to serve. Until we honestly acknowledge and systematically address that mismatch, the financing gap will remain – not because capital doesn’t exist, but because the architecture for delivering it to the businesses that need it doesn’t work.  

The Access Paradox

This is what the central paradox of MSME finance in Africa is about: the businesses most in need of capital are the least likely to access it, not because they are the least creditworthy in any meaningful economic sense, but because they are the least able to satisfy the documentation and collateral requirements that DFI lending architecture imposes.

Standard DFI lending criteria require audited financial statements, formal business registration, a track record of bank transactions, and tangible collateral, typically land or property. For established formal businesses with functioning administrative systems, these requirements are manageable. For the micro and small enterprises that make up  the vast majority of the MSME financing gap, they are prohibitive.

The result is a phenomenon that economists describe as collateral-driven exclusion: credit allocation that tracks asset ownership rather than productive potential or entrepreneurial capability. In contexts where asset ownership is itself distributed along historical lines of gender, geography, and social class, this means MSME finance flows disproportionately to businesses and entrepreneurs who are already relatively advantaged, the opposite of the inclusive growth mandate development finance institutions are meant to pursue.

The Problem with Intermediation Models

A significant portion of DFI capital reaches (or is intended to reach) MSMEs through financial intermediation: DFIs wholesale capital to commercial banks and microfinance institutions, who are then expected to on-lend to small businesses. The theory is sound. The practice is consistently disappointing and doesn’t move the needle in meeting the financing needs of micro and small firms.

Commercial banks that receive DFI wholesale funding at preferential rates often apply their standard lending criteria to the on-lending decisions. Preferential pricing does not translate into preferential access because the bottleneck is not the cost of capital but documentation and collateral requirements. As a result, DFI capital intended for underserved MSMEs often concentrates in larger, better-documented firms that commercial banks are already comfortable lending to.

Micro-Finance Institutions (MFIs), while reaching a broader and often more genuinely underserved population, face structural limitations of their own. Ticket sizes are often too small to support the growth investments that would move a micro enterprise toward the next tier of business development. Required repayment schedules are frequently misaligned with the cash flow cycles of the businesses being served, and the administrative cost of high-volume small-ticket lending limits the degree to which MFIs can provide the integrated support, beyond the loan itself, that growing MSMEs demonstrably need.

What Redesigned DFI Architecture Must Include

Closing the financing gap in any meaningful sense requires DFIs to move beyond incremental adjustments to existing products and seriously rethink the entire MSME finance delivery architecture.

Alternative credit assessment frameworks are a critical foundation for expanding access to finance. Mobile money transaction histories, utility bill payments, supplier references, and local market activity all offer valuable signals of creditworthiness that traditional models often overlook. Fintech lenders in African markets have demonstrated that leveraging these alternative data sources—together with tailored machine learning models—can produce credit scores with default-prediction accuracy equal to or surpassing conventional methods, while demanding far less documentation. DFIs must either build these capabilities internally or collaborate with financial institutions to develop them.

Blended finance structures that combine grants or concessional capital with commercial lending to de-risk first-time lending to MSMEs have shown consistent results in pilot programs across East and West Africa. When a guarantee facility partially backstops an MSME’s first loan, commercial intermediaries are more willing to lend, and the MSME builds a credit history that enables subsequent borrowing without the guarantee. The challenge is scaling these structures from pilot to program without the bureaucratic overhead that typically accompanies DFI-administered guarantee facilities.

Patient and flexible capital instruments are critically needed for growth-stage MSMEs. Revenue-based financing, in which repayment is structured as a percentage of monthly revenue rather than a fixed amortization schedule, is particularly well-suited to the variable cash flow environments in which most African MSMEs operate. Quasi-equity instruments that provide growth capital without requiring the full governance and reporting infrastructure of equity investment are similarly important for businesses that have outgrown microfinance but are not yet ready for venture capital.

The Data Infrastructure Imperative

In Africa, data collection presents significant challenges, requiring navigation of numerous obstacles, and these challenges are evident across MSME financing. As a result, data is perhaps the most consistently underinvested component of MSME finance infrastructure. The absence of reliable, comprehensive, and interoperable credit data across most African markets makes every lending decision more expensive, more conservative, and more likely to exclude businesses that would be creditworthy if their history were visible.

Governments and development partners must treat credit infrastructure investment, credit bureaus, collateral registries, digital business and individual identity systems, and interoperable financial data standards as essential enabling infrastructure for MSME finance, equivalent in importance to physical infrastructure for trade. The returns on this investment accrue across the entire financial system, not just to any single institution, which makes it a genuine public good that markets will systematically underprovide and governments must therefore lead.

Conclusion

The $331 billion financing gap won’t close by doing more of what’s already been done. The institutions, instruments, and intermediation models that created the gap cannot close it. What is required is a genuine redesign of MSME finance architecture, grounded in the operating reality of African small businesses, equipped with modern credit assessment tools, and structured around the goal of inclusive growth rather than institutional convenience. Development finance institutions have the mandate for this work. They now need the appetite for pure risk-taking that this bold step requires.

At KilSah Consulting, we sit at the intersection of policy, advisory, and implementation, working directly with governments, development agencies, and financial institutions to design and deliver programs that bridge exactly the gaps that help close the funding gap and empower MSMEs to survive, grow, and create jobs. From on-the-ground experience across multiple contexts, we understand how the mismatch between DFI lending architecture and MSME reality plays out in practice, and what it takes to close it. Redesigning that architecture is not a theoretical exercise; it requires partners who understand both the policy intent and the operational reality of the businesses the system is meant to serve. We are that partner, and we welcome a conversation with any institution ready to move from acknowledging the gap to genuinely closing it.

Written by:

Israel Effiong

Leave a Reply